| Nelson Haas | 1895 - 1905 |  |
| George J. Vogel | 1905 - 1909 |  |
| George L. Bennett | 1909 - 1917 |  |
| Edward Thomas Marlatt | 1918 - 1937 |  |
| Bontelle E. Lowe | 1937 - 1954 |  |
| Charles Cannon | 1954 - 1960 |  |
| Howard H. Bollerman | 1960 - 1966 |  |
| Carl Erasmus Padovano | 1966 - 1970 |  |
| Harold Bloom | 1970 - 1992 |  |
| Mark Bauman | 1992 - 1994 |  |
| Joseph DeFalco | 1994 - 2005 |  |
| Mark Porto | 2005 - present |  |